@bandswithothers I'm just joking. Good alters all the way.

@dr-j Got it. In that case, innocent blood, liliana, or diabolic edict are the hurt, lol

I loved all of these except for Jace the Mind Sculptor. I prefer my Jace to be immune to plowshares and the like

I could make a hellagood deck if I ignore the B&R list and that pesky "4 card limit" rule too.

@emopizza LOL, love it

I wish Maybe next year

I wish they'd stop making new formats. Eventually every set is going to be a format of some kind, and the prices of every card will skyrocket, just like what happened with 93/94. This means I can never sell any of my cards, even the supposed 10 cent chaff, as it will become a chase rare in some obscure format eventually and worth $40. I suppose I could just never sell any card ever and wait until cardboard in general becomes too expensive.

@nower1990 Yeah, I definitely don't think Leyline is a good card to run in Vintage. It's great in Modern, but not Vintage. I was just listing it as a white answer against turn 1 kills. It does have utility vs oath, and it also stops hurkylls if you are on null rods in addition to stony, but those are fringe uses.
Missteps are more useful in general and help dodge T1 kills at times. Mindbreak may only work once, but you are SBing it in G2, so if it works once, that's all you need. Then they also play in fear of it maybe in G3 when you maybe have it or maybe side it back out.
T1 kills aren't all THAT common, but PO can certainly pull it off and not with difficulty. I've lost plenty of times with a G1 on the draw where I drew 7 and died, won G2, then drew 7 and died on G3. PO can just be nuts like that.
Stony, Thalia, Rule, etc. are certainly the better white cards to use in general and will be great turns 2 and beyond. They just won't help turn 1 when you're on the draw.

@nower1990 That is a problem...you can sometimes just draw 7 cards and lose on the die roll.
For this reason, I think even a white-based deck needs to cheat and add 4x misstep. You also have another white answer against the storm kill - leyline of sanctity. That card is better in other formats, but it stops oath too, so there are worse cards to run.
Outside of that, the only way to NOT die on turn 1 is FoW. Not even shops, dredge, or anything else can deal with that. PO can even lotus out a mentor, dump moxen, tolarian, PO, and time walk and go nuts again...or tinker/time walk...so you lose on "turn 1" anyway. Sometimes they just have the nuts and you can't do anything.

edit - I suppose there's also mindbreak trap. Cheating on being "white" again, but a white deck can cast it vs PO.

@nower1990 Serenity is the anti-shop tech, not anti-PO. My white tech is good vs BSC and shops. The fact that any deck can jam 4 missteps means you can also path/plow BSC and have just as much chance of removing it. There's also things like forsake the worldly. Many chalk that card off as a 3 mana disenchant, but it exiles and also cycles. It's NEVER dead, and can do some neat top-deck-tutor -> cycle tricks later game.

My point being, white has PLENTY of tools to handle PO and other blue menaces as well as shops and dredge. Problem is, nobody on the VSL is playing such a deck online...so that means nobody will try it or think it's viable to do so.