last edited by diophan
Okay here's the first draft using the decklists from NA Champs:
A couple notes on the tags:
Thorn doesn't include null rod only Eldrazi decks ("Jacodrazi")
Blue Control includes the very controlling Nahiri Gush lists
Decks were tagged with Null Rod only when they had a Null Rod or Stony Silence in the maindeck
The dividing line for tagging a big blue style deck as combo was that I labelled Academy Combo and X City Vaults as Combo but not Tezz or Painter.
I tried to be as "hands off" in tagging as possible. For instance there were some off-the-wall Green/White Oath of Druids lists, legacy reanimator, and 2-Card Monte. Even though it didn't quite feel right to label them as Oath, Combo, and Shops respectively, I did in the interest of using the tags without putting my own bias into them.
However, if you want to see these archetypes without these lists, you can use the "Tag Search" feature. To see shops lists that aren't 2-Card Combo you include the Shops tag but exclude the Combo tag. To do the same for Oath or Combo you exclude the Other tag. To play around with these tags save a copy to your google drive so that you have edit privileges.
I thought it was interesting just how many vault/key decks were at Champs, which was obscured by the Archetype/Subarchetype classification scheme. Note that the Thorn winrate being higher than the Shops winrate does not necessarily mean that Thorn without Shops did better. The reason is that there are more Thorn mirror than Shops mirrors, which are excluded from the winrate calculations.
Let me know what you guys think!