@evouga I would caution this thinking. @Brass-Man got pretty unlucky flooding out multiple times in his 20 mana deck with 4 preordains vs some of these other decks running more land and in some cases fewer smoothing cantrips. That can happen, but I think if all these matches played more times, on paper, death's shadow would come out on top against most of them (the exception potentially being the MU he won, against Survival).

I enjoyed the show. I watch these anyways but I was really interested to see how all the Lavinia decks played out in this series. My take-away from this session was that while the card might be horrible to play against when it is out, the decks that play a strategy where a hate bear like this makes sense tend to have less dynamic win conditions.

Is Saffron Olive going to play next week?
"Hello everyone it's Seth, proooobably better known as Saffron Olive, and today we're going to be playing Panharmonicon Turbo-Jank iiiiiiiin Vintage..."
I can't wait.

Week three decklists are up: https://www.hipstersofthecoast.com/2019/01/vintage-super-league-season-9-week-3-decklists/

All four of this week's decks are more fringe. That should be fun.

The third pod will play today at 9 PM Eastern (GMT -5).
This Pod consists of:
Brian Kelly on Rector Flash
Seth Manfield on BUG Leovold
Erin Campbell on 2Card Monte
and Rachel Agnes on a EsperLaviniaThief list.

Full decklists and matches can be found here:

Again really intersting lists. While i dislike seeing Lavinias again, iam still really interested in Kellys, Erins and Rachels list.
Seeing Painter and Rector Flash should be awesome!

Edit: See the matches on twitch at: https://www.twitch.tv/magic

last edited by Aelien

@evouga Saffron Olive will play next week.

Brian Kelly with the sickest of lists as usual. Always a pleasure when his subtle machinations come to fruition.

@juice-mane said in VSL Season 9 Thread:

Brian Kelly with the sickest of lists as usual. Always a pleasure when his subtle machinations come to fruition.

Indeed! Like most of his decks this one looks like an inconsistent pile of unusual singletons (Mikokoro? Spellseeker??) that somehow manages to hum together in practice.

@evouga Exactly. Really looking forward to the games, and his commentary this coming stream.

The fourth pod will play today at 9 PM Eastern (GMT -5).
This Pod consists of:
SaffronOlive on Esper Humans
Matt Sperling on UWR Control
Kevin Cron on Lavinia's Xerox
Andy Markiton on Pitch Dredge

Full decklists and matches can be found here:

See the matches on twitch at: https://www.twitch.tv/magic

I suspected Saffron playing humans since he showed up on geekyjacksons stream with the deck yesterday, but i really hoped he would change his mind. Many people expected some cool brew from him, instead we get a pretty boring and easy to play deck. At least its uncommon (and hopefully stays that way). I guess it is not fair to expect from a new Vintage player to come up with a innovative brew, while only really knowing the format for a couple of weeks.

The other thing i want to complain about: Damn Lavinia, Azorius Renegade ...shes everywhere. Normally i dont have any problem with good new cards slipping in a lot of decks, but she is so damn boring. I guess this is not the Thread to rant about the card again, so lets leave it at that. At least Kevin packed a cool card with Spell Queller.

Andy of Pitch Dredge is cool to see in my opinion, especially with three spicy Spinning Darkness in the sideboard. If you look at the other decklists, you can see they are ready to deal with dredge, should be a fun night!

Shops is rather effective at cutting through a Lavinia dominated metagame (it's won all three challenges since RNA has been released), but the VSL isn't really a "balanced" metagame. I think some players avoid Shops because they think VSL viewers will find it boring and Andy and Rich avoided Shops because they thought their opponents would put them on it and might overload on hate. Then again, MTGO isn't particularly balanced right now as Walking Ballista doesn't work correctly with Foundry Inspector and opposing Lavinias. I just had to file for compensation because I couldn't cast a Walking Ballista for more than X=1 with Lavinia in play. It makes me not want to jam Shops again even though I think it's the best deck in the metagame and the appropriate choice right now for the Vintage leagues.

last edited by ChubbyRain

Fantastic play by all players tonight, and especially by Kevin Cron and Matt Sperling in the blue mirror!

I really liked SaffonOlive's deck but I think it under performed. The Thalia's never worked and Kitesail was not good. I think adding more spells for Mental Misstep and Flusterstorm would have helped. I also like the idea of main deck Damping Sphere for an Esper creature deck with Bob.

I have been messing around with a version of this deck for a while and I am running JVP and Snapcaster but I think Hero of Precinct One with JVP and some solid spells could work in this meta.

I’m not sure I agree about the Freebooters—-they looked pretty great to me, greatly slowing down the opponent’s ability to answer creature threats and attacking in the air. They don’t win the game on their own and unfortunately there wasn’t a sufficiently disruptive follow up during Seth’s matches.

By contrast the Thalia’s Lieutenant and Orzhov Pontiff looked very weak. I would replace them with more disruptive options like Spirit of the Labyrinth etc.

Week 5 decklists are up:


Shops will be getting it's first airtime (week 5!) and Dredge and combo appear again.

The real story is Seth's Oath deck. I love Oath as much as the next guy but it looks poorly positioned in this specific field. He may beat Andy but Seth is a dog in the PO matchup and has not a lot of Dredge hate in SB. Could be a rough week. I'm rooting for you Seth!

Week 6 decklists are up:


Andy Probasco (@Brass-Man, the wonderful owner of this website) on Enlightened Painter. Really cool deck and has a maindeck Rest in Peace!
Kevin Cron on Sai PO Storm
Erin Campbell (The Dredge Queen Shqueenge or @Oestrus) on what she calls "The Odd Couple" but regular people call Shredge or Drops.
Randy Buehler on PO Storm

Sounds like a lot of fun!

last edited by Rat3dE

Dredge Queen? @Oestrus has played shops in each list. This is a betrayal most foul.

@ChubbyRain What should I do to rectify this terrible situation? Should we rechristen her the SHOPS QUEEN?

  • 45
  • 6266