Damn, wish this was posted sooner!
Come join us at Top Deck Games for our next Vintage $1K on Saturday, November 23rd at 1pm!
WHEN: Saturday, November 23rd
• Registration: 11:00am - 12:50am
• Player Meeting/Round 1: 1:00pm
WHERE: Top Deck Games
55 Haddon Ave
Haddon Township, NJ 08108
ENTRY FEE: $35
FORMAT: Constructed - Vintage
• Comp REL, Deck lists required
• Swiss rounds with top 4/8 cut based on attendance
• Up to 15 playtest cards allowed
PRIZES: Based on standings, Store Credit
@ 6 swiss rounds
If she was symmetrical she also doesn't get restricted. The issues with these insane 2019 walkers are the effects being so one-sided. Karn, probably had to go regardless. This restriction will return the Pyroblast mirror to being more light sabery and less bludgeony but it just adds another turnip to the blue stew. The 2 x narsets will get replaced with a Dack that was sidelined, or a Saheeli to churn tokens, or more Oko in the builds with Forests.
These restrictions aren't a sustainable solution in anyway. What I don't understand is that given how Vintage (and Legacy) are worth no money at all to WotC why they don't admit the obvious and just let the eternal formats use different constructed rules. They already basically do this with Vintage in that it's the only format with a restricted list. Vintage and perhaps Legacy should just use the original Legends deck construction rules for Planeswalkers and then when the inevitable next dozen planeswalkers need restricting it's already baked in. This rule got changed in 1995 I think with Ice Age (so you could play 4 x General Jarkeld).
Just say in these hallowed ancient wizard battles each player can only have 1 of each walker in their deck. I'd actually just make it by name, e.g. Jace / Chandra / OKO because I hate planeswalkers but I can see an argument for 1 of just Jace, the Mindsculptor. Not sure how the flip walkers would work, I'd just restrict those also, fuck it.
@ten-ten If she were playable in white-heavy decks only, there's no way she gets restricted. More than likely though, blue just starts playing 4 tundras and Jeskai/Esper control becomes the big blue with Narset while other blue decks fade away. Blue will find a way thanks to dual lands.